Letters for the week of July 21-27, 2004 

What's killing bulky trash day? How about the profit motive? Plus thoughts on Mexican Americans and a few more bullying resources.

Page 2 of 2

Don't call the cops on the Dumpster diver; share your superfluous stuff with a smile. Free is best!
Helen Jones, Berkeley

"Portrait of the Times," Feature, 5/26

Los Estados Unidos of America
I read "Aztlan's big lie" (Letters, 7/7), and remembered the story regarding the Victor Castro mural. As a Hispanic, I feel it's time Hispanics take their heads out of their past. Mexico is just like any other civilization. It has oppressed and been oppressed. There's nothing honorable about it. It's life, plain and simple. Instead, we should focus on a bigger, more obvious picture when referring to where we came from. If we did, we might actually take a step toward helping citizens who come here seeking a better life, only to be branded as illegal aliens.

What bigger picture? How about Mexico being an American country? That's right. So many Hispanics differentiate between being born in "America" and/or being born in Mexico. Either way, they are American-born. Last time I checked, the United States has never had any exclusive rights to the title "America." In fact, Mexico was an American country before the United States was even established. So, instead of labeling hardworking American citizens as "illegal immigrants," maybe they should be seen as fellow Americans.

In my view, it's inevitable that the two countries will eventually agree on some form of unification. It's one thing to know where you came from, but it's quite another to sustain internal divisions because of historical technicalities. To me, it's petty and it doesn't help the people who need our cooperation the most, those in the here and now. Our fellow Mexicans/Americans could really benefit from a more unified front.
José, Oakland

He was Spanish
I just read Lance Beeson's letter in the July 9 Express. The writer makes several interesting points. However, I believe he is mistaken about Joaquin Isidro Castro's origins. As I received the story from two different sources, Joaquin Isidro Castro was born in Spain, most likely in Catalonia. His wife, Marie Martine Boutilier, was born in France and was a distant relative of the Bourbon family. Marie's ancestry caused a serious problem, since the Bourbon family and the Bourbon king of Spain were extremely unpopular in Catalonia during the mid-18th century. Joaquin and Marie moved to New Spain and settled in Sonora. All of their children were born there. Then, in 1775, they moved to California with the Anza expedition.

(By the way, I also am a seventh-generation descendant of Joaquin and Marie and a fifth-generation descendant of Victor.)
James M. Castro, Clancy, Montana

"The Bullying Industrial Complex," Feature, 6/16

Neither bullies nor victims
I want to thank Katy St. Clair for her article on bullies. As she pointed out, this is a huge problem. Street Safe Kids offers youth groups, grants, materials, and training so concerned adults can help strengthen kids. Children don't have to be bullies or victims. Perhaps you can help us get the word out.

I also have an article, "Making Cities Safe," on Senator Vasconcellos' Web site. Our communities need more involvement from the public to keep children safe. The article is at PoliticsofTrust.net/HTML/LIBRARY/ARTICLES/StephanieMann.htm
Stephanie L. Mann, program director, Street Safe Kids, Oakland

Maybe they were bullied
I haven't linked to your article because your examples were drawn mainly from grade school and my Web site Raven Days (RavenDays.org) is about secondary-school bullying, but I thought it was pretty good.

Note, however, that there was absolutely nothing "automatic" about the assumption that Harris and Klebold acted the way they did because they were bullied. On the contrary, the initial assumption on the part of most authorities was that it was either a purely random act of violence ("We can never know"), or else the boys' attempt to imitate a first-person action-adventure shooting game. Some, perhaps many, people still believe one of those two things.

For my part, I'm not sure that I believe that Harris and Klebold weren't bullied. From the descriptions of Columbine's high school culture, I'd think they would almost have had to have been, even if not as much as the real Trenchcoat Mafia.

Also, while you may be right about the recent influx of commercial antibullying sites, please realize that there are a group of sites run by people who aren't in this for money. You can tell who we are, because the commercial sites don't link to us. My site is one of them. I put in about an hour a day; I have since 1999, and I've never made a dime from it. Brenda's The Wounded Child (TheWoundedChild.org) and Stan's Stop Bullying Now! (StopBullyingNow.com) are more commercial than my site, but not much more so. Stan has written an excellent book on bullying, the best I've seen. (And no, I'm not getting a kickback for saying so.)
Meredith Dixon, Mannington, West Virginia

"Berkeley Intifada," Feature, 5/19

Non sequitur
No sane person would justify the harassment of an American of Arab descent because of the terrorist actions of Saudi nationals on September 11, 2001. Nor would any reasonable human being condone the intimidation of persons of Chinese descent because of China's occupation of Tibet, or support an attack on a person of Indian descent because of India's control of most of disputed Jammu-Kashmir, etc. Yet a great many pro-Palestinian activists see attacks on American Jews as justified because of these activists' opposition to Israel's policies -- and, truth be told, their opposition to Israel's very existence.
Aharon S.R. Silver, Walnut Creek


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments will be removed.

Latest in Letters

Most Popular Stories

Special Reports

The Beer Issue 2020

The Decade in Review

The events and trends that shaped the Teens.

Best of the East Bay


© 2020 Telegraph Media    All Rights Reserved
Powered by Foundation