Journalists Refuse to Be Interviewed 

Reporters who were secretly taped by Jerry Brown's ex-spokesman would not tell their stories to official investigators looking into the matter.

When the Alameda County District Attorney's Office announced last week that it would not file charges against a former spokesman for Jerry Brown, the news barely generated a whisper. It was a stark contrast to last November, when the San Francisco Chronicle splashed a story across its front page about how attorney general flak Scott Gerber had secretly taped the phone calls of six journalists. In an interview on Monday with the Express, District Attorney Nancy O'Malley revealed why the Chronicle and other newspapers may have allowed a page-one story to die a quiet death — the journalists refused to be interviewed.

O'Malley said that when her office contacted the reporters — including longtime Chronicle journalist Carla Marinucci — they referred her to their attorneys. The attorneys then cited the state's shield law as to why they wouldn't talk.

Marinucci did not return phone calls for this story, but the decision to refuse an interview is odd after her paper made such a huge deal about the tapings. It's also unclear as to how the shield law, designed to protect confidential sources, would apply to a case in which reporters were unknowingly taped by a government official. Gerber resigned over the incident because he violated his office's prohibition on taping people without consent. O'Malley got involved when Brown asked her to conduct an independent investigation.

Without the reporters' version of events, O'Malley said she had no choice but to dismiss the case. However even if the reporters had been interviewed, O'Malley might not have filed charges. The reason is that she said she would have to prove that the reporters had an "expectation of privacy." And that would be a tough case to make, because all of the calls were for "on-the-record interviews."

O'Malley declined to discuss her decision's ramifications. But her standard would lead one to conclude that all "on-the-record" conversations between journalists and sources can be secretly taped by either party without fear of repercussions. And that could represent a significant change in local journalistic practice.

Mercury's Ugly Record

The flap over the secret recordings stemmed from a story by Marinucci about Mercury Insurance, the state's third largest auto insurer. Marinucci's piece concerned a ballot summary by Brown's office that neglected to note that a statewide initiative backed by Mercury will allow auto insurers to raise rates on low-income drivers. Coincidentally, Marinucci broke another story this week, revealing that Mercury has been involved in some ugly practices.

According to a report by the state Department of Insurance that Marinucci obtained, Mercury engaged in discriminatory and possibly illegal activities for more than a decade. It's not clear whether Mercury will face any penalties, but consumer advocate Harvey Rosenfield told Marinucci that if voters approve Proposition 17 in June, it will allow the insurance company to "legalize the kind of discriminatory surcharges that they were caught doing by investigators."

The state investigation, which ran from the mid 1990s to 2004, revealed that Mercury apparently discriminated against artists, actors, dancers, military personnel, emergency vehicle drivers, and people who had been in accidents caused by others, in violation of state law. The company also allegedly duped new customers by quoting discounts that it never provided and requested that its customers reveal their "national origin."

Prop. 17 would overturn existing consumer protections, allowing Mercury and other insurers to charge higher rates to people who have let their auto insurance lapse. The company is advertising the proposition as a way to give discounts to drivers who have maintained their insurance, but consumer experts generally agree that the measure would adversely impact low-income motorists the most. Attorney General Brown also greatly helped Mercury by not mentioning this fact in the official ballot summary for the June Election.

Measure B Clobbered

Measure B, the widely criticized initiative sponsored by Alameda Point developer SunCal, lost badly at the polls last week, garnering a pathetic 15 percent of the vote. The "no" votes accounted for 85 percent, meaning the measure lost by a whopping 70 points. The lopsided loss came as no surprise to SunCal officials who made the unusual move of conceding defeat the day before the polls opened.

Three-Dot Roundup

The Berkeley Daily Planet was defrauded by its payroll contractor for possibly hundreds of thousands of dollars, according Becky O'Malley, the paper's editor and co-owner. ... An Oakland City Council committee referred a proposal by City Attorney John Russo to double the city's campaign contribution limits to the city's Public Ethics Commission. ... In a speech to the Oakland chambers of commerce last week, Mayor Ron Dellums appeared to be setting the stage for a reelection bid. ... Campaign finance records show that mayoral candidate Don Perata was paid $260,000 last year by the state's powerful prison guard's union for "campaign consulting," even though the union mounted no political campaigns. ... And the campaign of Republican Senate hopeful Carly Fiorina became infamous with a web video portrayed of rival Tom Campbell as "a demon sheep."


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments will be removed.

Latest in Seven Days

  • Libby Schaaf's Moment

    The Oakland mayor's decision to publicly take on President Trump and his anti-immigration policies was not only politically smart, it was the right thing to do.
    • Mar 7, 2018
  • You're Not a Progressive If You're Also a NIMBY

    Why housing is a liberal imperative.
    • Feb 28, 2018
  • The Warriors' Empty Gesture

    The team's new Town jerseys and logo finally recognize Oakland after all these years. But they mean nothing if the Warriors refuse to pay their $40 million debt.
    • Feb 21, 2018
  • More »

Author Archives

  • Turning the Page

    My commitment to regaining your trust.
    • Jul 18, 2018
  • Measure A R.I.P.

    Recent state laws that require cities to build more housing - along with new legislation in Sacramento - are making no-growth initiatives like Alameda's Measure A obsolete.
    • Mar 13, 2018
  • More»

Most Popular Stories

  • Disappeared in Death

    Homeless and mentally ill, Joshua Pawlik was unconscious right before four Oakland police officers killed him in March. His family and friends are seeking answers.
  • Oakland Unified Moves to Save Gülen Movement Charter School

    OUSD plans to appoint a director to BayTech's board while an ongoing investigation delves into allegations of financial mismanagement.
  • BayTech Charter School Under Investigation

    The principal suddenly resigned after the school's board accused him of fraud, but the controversy raises questions about the school's links to the Gülen movement.
  • A’s Off-Field Moves Build Winning Environment

    Chemistry between Oakland players and coaches, as well as between the franchise and East Bay fans, has been a big part of the recipe for the A’s’ resurgence.
  • Self-Care as a Political Act

    In the East Bay, women of color and queer people are making alternative health-care practices accessible and culturally relevant to their communities — as well as a key part of their activism.

Special Reports

Summer Guide 2018

It's the Express' guide to all things summer!

© 2018 East Bay Express    All Rights Reserved
Powered by Foundation