Field of Bad Dreams 

In its rush to create sports facilities at Harrison Park, Berkeley overlooked nasty environmental realities. It should have known better.

Page 2 of 3

The parents, led by Doug Fielding, president of the nonprofit Association of Sports Fields Users, didn't hesitate to use their political clout, Wooly says. "Fielding was heavy-handed, overbearing, single-minded, and shortsighted during the entire process," she says. "It was understood by the council members that this project was to be approved quickly and questions about health hazards were swept away in the rush."

While assistant city attorney Cowan admits there may have been missteps by his office, he says they were unrelated to pressure from soccer parents or even the council. But Wood, a city-council candidate who was largely responsible for forcing the city to conduct the current air study, says council members had to suspect there were environmental problems with the property. They simply didn't want to look too closely. "The soccer parents rode over city process like a runaway train," Wood says.

Talk to the parents and you'll hear a different story, perhaps surprisingly so. It is their children, after all, who will be using the site. This difference in perspective stems from the fact that Berkeley is sorely lacking in open spaces for recreation. Harrison now hosts two of six soccer fields that are used to their full capacity by the thousand-member local soccer club.

Despite the chromium-6 fiasco and the discouraging air study results, the majority of soccer parents and homeless advocates appear undaunted -- indeed, the soccer club adds members with every season, according to its organizers. Living in a built-up urban environment, they say, entails certain compromises. The parents argue that the benefits of organized sports are evident in the health and attitudes of their children, while the health hazard posed by exposing their children to dirty air for a few hours a week during soccer season are uncertain.

Fred Hetzel, a member of the soccer club's board of directors, says his two children will continue to play on the site. Hetzel says he's spoken with the air district and is confident that playing soccer a few hours per week isn't dangerous. "If parents saw their children wheezing and keeling over on the field, of course they would be worried," says Doug Fielding. "Instead parents see their kids coming home happy, red-faced, and exhausted, and that's what you want as a parent."

Homeless advocates take a similar position: Boona cheema, executive director of Building Opportunities for Self Sufficiency, the nonprofit behind the Sherman Village project, says she'd be happy to build it in Tilden Park where the views are great and the air is fresh, but she doesn't expect that to happen anytime soon. "What do you think the answer is going to be when you ask a homeless mother with two kids if she would rather live on the streets or in safe, warm housing in west Berkeley?" she asks.Warm, perhaps, but how safe? The air study shows that levels of a dangerous air pollutant known as particulate matter 10, or PM10, exceeds state standards an average of eight times a month. While the levels are measured in 24-hour averages, particulate pollution appears to peak between 1 p.m. and 3 p.m. -- coinciding with weekend soccer games. But exactly how the high PM10 levels may affect the health of young soccer players who pant up and down the field two to six hours a week, or that of the families who may soon live on the site, is hard to pin down.

State scientific and regulatory agencies including the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment and the Bay Area Air Quality Management District agree that children with respiratory conditions such as asthma and bronchitis should be closely monitored if they are going to participate in sports or live in housing at the site. But, they say, the risk to healthy children may be minimal.

"There may be a small increase in risk of respiratory symptoms in healthy children, given the data I've looked at," says Michael Lipsett, a public health physician with the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment, after examining one month's air pollution data from the site. "What that would mean to the average individual is hard to tell."

Lipsett agrees with Fielding that soccer parents must weigh the benefits of playing organized sports at Harrison Park against the potential hazard of what he described as a common air-quality condition in the state's urban areas.

But it is also true that PM10 is particularly nasty. Associated with urban automobile exhaust and industrial activity, the particles consist of metals, soot, soil, dust, and liquids. They are about ten microns in diameter, an ideal size for inhalation. "PM10 is among the most harmful of all air pollutants. When inhaled, the tiny particles evade the respiratory system's natural defenses and lodge deep in the lungs. Health problems begin as the body reacts to these foreign particles," states the air district's Web site. "PM10 can increase the number and severity of asthma attacks, cause or aggravate bronchitis and other lung diseases, and reduce the body's ability to fight infections."

Lipsett's own agency was mandated in 1999 by the Children's Environmental Protection Act to review state standards for PM 10 to assure they adequately protected "the public, including infants and children, with an adequate margin of safety."

As a result of that review, the California Air Resources Board strengthened the annual standard for PM10 from thirty micrograms per cubic meter to twenty; the new standards are expected to go into effect early next year. Standards for the 24-hour average, the measurement used by the Harrison Park air study, will stay the same. The air at the Harrison site, however, exceeds limits set by both the annual and 24-hour standards.

Despite the troubling environmental issues, Parks, Recreation, and Waterfront Director Lisa Caronna is still a Harrison Park booster. "Knowing what is known about the property now, I would still support this project," she says. "This project is a winner for the residents of Berkeley."

Tags: ,


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments will be removed.

Latest in News

Author Archives

Most Popular Stories

Special Reports

The Beer Issue 2020

The Decade in Review

The events and trends that shaped the Teens.

Best of the East Bay


© 2020 Telegraph Media    All Rights Reserved
Powered by Foundation