Dilemmas in the Holy Land 

A Nazi hunter finds tangled emotions in Walk on Water.

Most contemporary thrillers aren't concerned with moral dilemmas; the emphasis is on action and intrigue. The Israeli film Walk on Water -- which, conveniently for American audiences, is primarily in English (the rest is Hebrew and German with English subtitles) -- not only raises questions about right and wrong, but also addresses issues of intolerance, bigotry, forgiveness, and identity that will resonate with all sorts of viewers. In other words, you don't have to be Jewish ... or German, Israeli, male, female, gay, or straight ... to relate.

Directed by Eytan Fox (Yossi & Jagger), the film opens with an assassination. Eyal (Lior Ashkenazi), a steely Mossad agent with a hard outer shell and an even more rigid, callous interior, kills a suspected Palestinian terrorist in front of the man's wife and young son. Not even the boy's tear-stained face moves him. So divorced is Eyal from his own emotions that when his wife commits suicide, he cannot bring himself to weep.

Eyal's new assignment is to track down and "terminate" Alfred Himmelman, a former Nazi war criminal who has never been brought to justice. He protests, arguing that it's a waste of time. Born a generation after the end of World War II, he doesn't understand why some Israelis are still so consumed with the Holocaust. In order to discover Himmelman's whereabouts, Eyal is ordered to befriend the old man's grandchildren. Pia (Carolina Peters) left Germany several years ago and now lives on an Israeli kibbutz. Her younger brother Axel (Knut Berger) is coming for a visit, and Eyal poses as a tour guide assigned to show him around the country.

At first surly and unsociable toward the pair, Eyal discovers that both Pia and Axel are extraordinarily kind, knowledgeable, and fair-minded people. Perhaps his greatest shock comes when he learns that tall, strapping Axel is gay. Refusing to mask his disgust but unable to abandon his mission, Eyal is forced to interact with Axel on a daily basis. Slowly, almost against his will, he finds his assumptions about people being called into question.

Just when Eyal thinks he can wash his hands of the two, he discovers that Alfred Himmelman is very much alive and may be coming out of hiding to attend his son's -- Pia and Axel's father's -- birthday party in Germany. Mossad orders Eyal to Germany, where he is forced to accept Axel's hospitality while plotting to assassinate the young man's grandfather.

Walk on Water explores a wealth of issues and conflicting ideologies -- those that separate people and those that reside within an individual. Certain prejudices are obvious. Others reveal themselves more slowly: Eyal's growing awareness of how his society's emphasis on being tough has stunted his own emotional development, and how Israel's fear of being victimized again has blinded its citizens to their own mistreatment of the Palestinians.

Even more daunting are the choices Pia -- and, later, Axel -- must face concerning their family history. Questions of loyalty, betrayal, self-respect, social responsibility, and forgiveness are not easy to reconcile. But then, director Fox doesn't want them to be. All of his characters must live with painful truths, not only about themselves but about their families and homelands.

Much of the film's success relies on the three lead actors, all of whom give nuanced and convincing performances. Pia is relaxed and smiles easily, but there is a depth to her eyes that suggests a deep-seated sadness and great strength of character. Axel exudes both masculinity and gentleness. The chemistry between brother and sister is also totally believable.

Ashkenazi is perhaps the biggest surprise. At the beginning of the film, he seems to have very little depth (as if perhaps he had been hired strictly for his good looks) until one realizes that he is playing a man completely tuned out to his own sense of unease. Impatient, emotionally remote, physically stiff, he is uncomfortable in his own skin. Whenever he is onscreen, he makes the viewer uneasy, as if he'll suddenly explode.

His exposure to Pia and Axel, who do not fit into the boxes he has assigned them, confuses him. He is too smart, however, not to recognize that his conceptions are being challenged, and the ensuing internal struggle is clear.

The film ends on a challenging note. Then, however, it tacks on a sop to those who demand unequivocal happiness. It's the one thing about Walk on Water that doesn't feel real. n A Nazi hunter finds tangled emotions in Walk on Water.


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments will be removed.

Latest in Movie Review

Author Archives

  • Thugs and Kisses

    A South African street fighter finds new life in the wrenching redemption tale Tsotsi.
    • Mar 15, 2006
  • In the Face of Evil

    Sophie Scholl relives the last days of an anti-Nazi hero.
    • Mar 1, 2006
  • More»

Most Popular Stories

Special Reports

The Beer Issue 2020

The Decade in Review

The events and trends that shaped the Teens.

Best of the East Bay


© 2020 Telegraph Media    All Rights Reserved
Powered by Foundation