Letters for April 16 

Readers sound off about Berkeley police, World Can't Wait, De La Fuente's Tidewater vote, Nancy Nadel, sleeping with your seven-year-old son, and more.


"Who Baited Whom at Berkeley Rallies?" News, 3/26

Both Sides Hide

So now your intrepid police beat reporter Anneli Rufus wants us to believe there was no police violence at the Feb. 22 protests in Berkeley, that those poor riot-gear-clad officers were provoked and threatened by a group of Berkeley High School students yelling at them. And Berkeley taxpayers paid how much in overtime for this farce!?!

I personally witnessed police shove one man to the ground in front of the police station, as I'm sure the dozens of others who were outraged that the cops started pushing students around also saw. This was after a youth was arrested and students and World Can't Wait folks gathered in front of the police station to call for the youth's release. Does poor old Police Chief Hambleton really expect us to believe that the police were afraid the students would try to storm the station to release their comrade? The students aren't that stupid, as BHS spokesperson Mark Coplan seems to think. He insults the intelligence of these thinking young people when he says they are "fourteen, fifteen – literally babies."

My fifteen-year-old son was among the protesters. He's a veteran of dozens of protests since he was a baby, including the first protest against the then-impending Iraq war in October 2002 in Washington, DC. He's lived almost half his young life under the shadow of George Bush's war; he and his fellow students know they are targets of the predators at the Marine recruiting station, and that the endless oil war/terror war is running out of willing cannon fodder. I was so proud of my son that he skipped school March 19 to protest again and chanted "Hell No! We Won't Go!" But Anneli Rufus is just outraged that students would commit the heinous crime of skipping classes, saying nothing about the war crimes these students refuse to be part of.

To suggest that these intelligent young students are stupidly following the World Can't Wait crowd because they are given free T-shirts and bandanas is ridiculous. They can think for themselves. I told my son to be careful and be aware that there are agents provocateur who do try to incite violence. I know from 25-plus years in leftist politics that the Revolutionary Communist Party has engaged in this before; their cult of personality around Chairman Avakian doesn't serve any useful purpose. It's certainly possible that World Can't Wait recruiters hide behind youth while screaming at police. It's certain that Marine recruiters hide behind police while lying to our youth.

Paul Burton, Oakland

Embedded Journalism Right Here in Berkeley

If you're looking for "embedded" journalism that lies in the service of an illegitimate war, you don't need to turn on Fox News. Just check out Anneli Rufus' article "Who Baited Whom at Berkeley Rallies?" Not only is Rufus' attack on antiwar protesters one-sided, quoting extensively from a police spokesperson and other pro-police sources without any commentary from World Can't Wait, but the article completely evades the substance and nature of the two sides that have been facing off in Berkeley. On one side are the protesters, tired of waiting (five years now) for their "elected representatives" to stop an illegal and immoral war that has already taken 1 million Iraqi lives and forced 5 million to flee their homes, and determined to bring it to a halt by stopping the lying recruiters from sucking more young people into it. In opposition, pro-war forces (bearing signs like "Waterboard the Liberals") are trying to intimidate and silence what they perceive as a real threat to the status quo.

Rufus quotes the school district's PR man, Mark Coplan, who accuses World Can't Wait activists of provoking police while "hiding behind" the youth (whom Coplan calls "literally babies"). This is false, condescending, and paternalistic. The youth have minds and opinions of their own. In fact, one of the best things to happen in Berkeley in a long time is that so many high school students have taken stopping the war into their own hands. 

Who is really manipulating the youth? Antiwar activists who tell the truth about the war, or the recruiters with billions of dollars at their disposal to lie to the youth? Who lurks around grade schools in souped-up Hummers, telling kids that war is like a video game? Do recruiters mention that one-third of women soldiers report being raped in the service? Or that this war is based on 935 lies told by the Bush regime? Do they describe the war crimes that US troops are ordered to carry out every day, including torture, collective punishment, and targeting of innocent civilians? If the recruiters told the truth, no one would join. Nothing about this war and occupation is "honorable" and troops that carry out these orders should not be supported. 

Military recruiters do not have any "right" to be in Berkeley or anywhere else, since their "right" to recruit conflicts with the right of the Iraqi people to live and to be free of an illegitimate war and occupation. 

Giovanni Jackson, World Can't Wait Youth Organizer, Berkeley

"Rezoning Plan Benefits Pals of De La Fuente," Full Disclosure, 3/12

It's Our Estuary

I can remember going for a walk along the estuary near the so-called Tidewater area by High Street in the late 1960s and a guard pulling a gun on me, ordering me to get out of their private property or he was going to shoot. Me, just some knucklehead brown kid wanting to enjoy a walk along the water's edge on a Sunday afternoon, having my life threatened for not knowing I was trespassing on some industrial property seems pretty crazy. Even at that tender age, it wasn't the first time I had looked down the barrel of a cocked gun. I called him every swear word I could think of, daring him to do his worst, but eventually I retreated back to High Street, steaming mad.

Now, almost 40 years later, Ignacio De La Fuente is trying to create access to the estuary right in the same area I was trespassing. In Mr. Gammon's March 12 article he would have you believe that there is some sinister plot to make De La Fuente's friends rich on 2.5 acres of land. However, it is common knowledge that one of Mr. De La Fuente's longtime goals has been to open up access to the estuary for everyone, which I think is great.

Industrial land is an important issue. As an Oakland construction contractor, I know how hard it is to find. But when certain industrial properties become available, such as properties along the waterfront, we want to make those areas available for all to enjoy. Crushing rock or cement plants or storing huge stacks of cargo containers are important, but I think most people will agree that regaining access to our waterfronts is more important and the smart thing to do. Why would anyone want to keep a potentially beautiful waterfront area inaccessible to the general public? I thank Ignacio De La Fuente for having the brains and the balls to fight for us to gain access to the waterfronts of Oakland. It's our estuary and we shouldn't have to trespass in order to enjoy it.

Jay Dodson, Oakland

"Though Oakland Is Up in Arms About It, Crime Is Actually Down," Full Disclosure, 3/19

What About Nadel's Idiocy?

As usual, the East Bay Express seems to have it out for Ignacio, and leaves many stones unturned. Let's have some real investigative reporting and get some coverage on Nancy Nadel's idiotic campaign to reduce density in the urban core of downtown Oakland (lowering height limits), which directly contradicts sustainable urban planning principles.

Regarding the supposed success of Dellums and team in corralling funds from the Measure Y to pay for more officers, let's get some in-depth coverage of the details. Among other things, this move is said by those who follow this to be both illegal and shortsighted as the officers' funding will not be met in future budgets given deficits and projected shortfalls. None of this is mentioned in your article here.

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments will be removed.

Latest in Letters

Most Popular Stories

Special Reports

Holiday Guide 2016

A guide to this holiday season's gifts, outings, eats, and more.

Taste, Fall 2016

Everything you need to know about dining in and out in the East Bay.

© 2016 East Bay Express    All Rights Reserved
Powered by Foundation