Benchmark’s out-of-the-way location has been a mixed blessing. On the one hand, the pizzeria hasn’t really had to compete with, say, a nearby Dopo or Pizzaiolo. On the other hand, the restaurant flies almost completely under the radar among non-Kensingtonians. But Benchmark’s well-blistered, crisp-bottomed “Neo-Neapolitan” pizzas are well worth a trip to Kensington’s Colusa Circle neighborhood. So are the seasonal vegetable dishes, the comforting house-made pastas (try the “priest stranglers” with Bolognese sauce), and the best-in-class kids’ menu. We appreciate the warm, easy-going service and the way the Benchmark feels more approachable and less precious than many of its Cal-Italian counterparts in Oakland or Berkeley — despite the fact that the food is just as good and the sourcing of ingredients just as conscientious.
Hours: Hours: Mon.–Thu. 5–9 p.m., Fri.–Sat. 5–9:30 p.m.
Payment Type: Cash, all major credit cards