Oakland, Berkeley, And East Bay News, Events, Restaurants, Music, & Arts
I had my queer wedding at humanist hall and never would have been able to afford to celebrate anywhere else in the Bay. I've been to dozens of amazing community events here. Even the idea that the city would fine HH for the "nuisance" of holding an event for SF women against rape indicates how screwed up their priorities are. Stop hiding behind bureaucratic indifference, Oakland. Rescind the fine and affirm the importance of community gathering spaces. Pass legislation if you have to.
If there is a petition to save the Humanist Hall, where is it and how do I sign it?
Who's around there to complain? Is this a set-up to try to get the property for some new million-dollar condos for the Google set?
This comment was removed because it violates our policy against anonymous comments. It will be reposted if the commenter chooses to use his or her real name.
I was a member of the Fellowship of Humanity, attended many meetings in the Humanist Hall, and even slept there a short time when I was homeless. SAVE THIS SPACE!
Who said there are no condos there... ? Having watched the youtube footage of our friend Thomas Lo, Im guessing he lives in the "contemporary Mediterranean lofts" at 426 27th Street. They were built in 2003, so the timing would be right that the noise complaints would start rolling in from that building right about 2005.
Thank God, or not-god in the case of the Humanists that the fine, upstanding government of the city of Oakland has taken the brave stand of declaring a nuisance exactly where a nuisance ought to be: where people celebrate significant life events, where people explore creative ideas, where people talk about social justice.
A nuisance indeed.
City hall, that is.
The Humanist Center has an important history in our community providing us with a center that is affordable to working-class people. I have attended a range of events there ranging from a talk by a local journalist returned from the Middle East to my friends combination birthday celebration/art show. The city needs to work with the center not label it a nuisance or impose unreasonable fines.
The first sentence of the article is not clear. Over 1500 people have signed a petition stating that they DO NOT believe the Humanist Hall is a nuisance or should be considered a nuisance. You should consider clarifying. Also has the city officially declared the Humanist Hall a nuisance? Or is it just Thomas Lo and some other nameless neighbors? Have the neighbors who have complained declared themselves publicly? Is it public record?
My wife and I were married at the Humanist Hall in March. We abided by the 10pm sound restriction, and had a wonderful time with friends and family. We would not have been able to afford such a wonderful event at any other venue, as the Humanist Hall is priced to accommodate the needs of the community. Please support this Oakland treasure.
The 1500 signatories are supporters of the church, not opponents. And I don't know why you're blaming "condo owners" for this; there are no condos anywhere near the church. The only residential structure nearby is a set of townhomes, built over a decade ago.
This is egregious and represents everything ugly about newbies coming to this town. This place does have church status won during the damn McCarthy years. It has been a progressive bastion for it's whole existence . Everything from progrssive seders, Angela Davis Defense, Venceremos Brigade to Rainbow were organized there. There needs to be a petition going the other way. I live around the corner from Beebe Memorial and we get their preaching and their choir, but we as neighbors appreciate what they bring to the community. These people, the nuisance neighbors in the condos need to recognize that a place like thisis what has held the fabric of community together to even let them consider buying a condo in that area. I do not know how the hell these condos got 1500 signatories, they do not have that many people living there. So I too am inclined to beleive that there are folks scamming with an eye to buying the property.
Judy Junita: Accusing someone of being Uncle Tom is also not right. You should always respect the other person even if they are not right.
Bravo to Judy Juanita for bringing this issue to our attention. The bottom line is this. Beyond signs and assignments, there is humanity. There the truth lies.
I, a gay white man, was an usher for years, even while I was transitioning into my current profession as a music and theater critic. If I had encountered a situation such as this, I would have looked Judy in the eye, listened to her story, and felt her energy. Once I did that, it would have become clear that there was a misunderstanding somewhere. Then I would have gone about explaining the situation to both sides, and sticking with it until it was resolved (unless some "higher up" shooed me away).
By now, it is likely that the ushers who were involved with this situation have heard about what happened. It would be great to hear from them. Certainly Berkeley Rep has no right to deny them free speech.
One last thing. I learned a long time ago that no straight person can adequately understand a LGBT person's situation in a homophobic society. Ditto for men and women, whites and blacks, etc. Anyone who wasn't there, yet declares they know what "really" happened and what Judy Juanita is really about, isn't talking about either the situation or her; they're talking about themselves.
jason victor serinus
Where's our Patron Saint of the Arts Mayor now? What's up Libby, snail car unavailable for your photo op? This is an Oakland Arts Institution and you oughta get to steppin on using your artsy fartsy might to keep RSP in business.
RPS is a fixture in the community and I am sad to see them move, especially considering how much they've done for the community. There should be some type of affordable storefront program for organizations making positive contributions to neighborhoods. The extinct Mama Buzz, and the soon-to-be missing RPS, makes me feel nostalgic for a time that was so recent. I supported the Indiegogo campaign, have curated an exhibition there, and I hope they find a bigger and better place in the East Bay to keep the DIY and DIT arts thriving!
A friend who is a playwright/director/theater producer wrote in reply to all of this:
"It’s a trip, isn’t it, Judy? We actually were able to diversify our audiences but it took constant work over many years. I think we were one of the few theaters that actually had success, because we believed there were solid markets in the black and Latin communities....Of course, it starts with a diverse staff, advisory councils, openness to feedback. We found, from our visiting actors, that our city was the most racist town they had experienced anywhere in the country, including the deep South. We got great feedback from a black woman on our staff who also handled a local jazz program. She told us she could actually see our white ushers flinch when black people came to the door. In our pre-show speeches, we had to clarify the diversity of our audiences and tell ushers and ticket takers, not to “flinch”. Can you believe it? She also told us that we should put a greeter out in front of theater, as in a black church, to welcome people. That became part of her job. We also found group sales were essential to bringing in people who were uncomfortable trying out theater on their one… it didn’t matter if they were black, white working class or Latino. Another black woman handled group sales and she was terrific, very quiet in her own way, but fearless about approaching any ethnic group to make a sale. Good group sales people also tend to show up to take care of groups. When people come in a group, they might come later on their own.
"And then, racism is so pervasive, you have to retrain your staff every few years because of turn over. It’s really wild, isn’t it? You wouldn’t think this would be a problem in Berkeley, would you? But I grew up in Berkeley during the 50s, and there were vicious wars about real estate restrictions… the original Prop 13 was about that, as I recall. It’s good to hear from you now and then, and I’m glad you’re so active, and vocal, when necessary.
"BTW… my dad grew up in Oakland, and we learned a lot from him about how to break down the walls. We were raised as Berkeley Mormons, but my dad taught us to argue Sunday School teachers that withholding the priesthood from blacks was a false doctrine. That became interesting once we moved to Los Angeles in 1960 and were surrounded by John Birchers."
I had a similar experience at the Berkeley Rep. June of 1997. At the invitation of Vinnie Burrows, who performed in my play,” Hubba City” at the Nuyorican Cafe, I'd gone to the Berkeley Rep. to see her and Delores Mitchell star in“Having Our Say: The Delany Sisters’ First 100 years.” A young black man, an employee of the Rep., asked me hostile questions, followed me around and even snooped on me as I talked with the two actresses.It was an uncomfortable experience. However, when I produced Wajahat Ali's play,"The Domestic Crusaders" at the Rep. in 2008, the staff cooperated without incident.But Judy Juanita has put her finger on it.Racial profiling is rampant in Berkeley.
Sam Levin's piece, as well as Polly Ikonen's quote, is rhetorically structured to invalidate, or place suspicion, on Juanita's statement. If Ikonen is really interested in "building audiences" that are more diverse, she would not simply try to explain away this incident and the perceptions that others--not "regulars"--have of this institution. Her statement, however, has the effect of closing the door---gently of course--on this important dialogue.
East Bay Express All Rights Reserved
Powered by Foundation