The Mexican Rosa Parks

"Like Jesús, Elvira Arellano was a brown-skinned alien who sparked equal parts rage and praise while promoting their movement."

August 29, 2007

Dear Mexican: Do you agree with immigration rights activists calling Elvira Arellano, who is an illegal immigrant AND a criminal, I might add, the Mexican Rosa Parks? The very idea that these people refer to her as such is deeply disturbing. Rosa Parks was a legal resident of this country and took a stand against the injustices against African Americans AND, by extension, all other minorities in this country. I can't imagine what goes through the minds of some of these people when they made ludicrous statements comparing Arellano to Parks. I have a problem with illegal immigrants, period! I don't care where they come from on this planet, illegal IS illegal.
Swing Low, Sweet Migra

Article Tools

Dear Gabacha: You're right. How dare yaktivists compare Elvira Arellano (an recently deported illegal Mexican immigrant who earned national attention this year by seeking sanctuary in a Chicago church) to Rosa Parks! Besides, everyone knows the better historical counterpart is Jesus. Think about it: Like Jesús, Arellano was a brown-skinned alien who sparked equal parts rage and praise while promoting their movement. Both lived in defiance of authorities who obsessed over laws that ignored the Segundo Coming. Arellano and the Nazarene knew their ultimate martyrdom yet met grim destiny with serenity, asking followers not to react angrily but rather allow God's will. I already hear the gnashing teeth of Know Nothings — but what about the fake Social Security number? The breaking of federal law? The fact that ILLEGAL IS ILLEGAL? — but let the record show that no matter how you spin it, Arellano's tale is biblical in its intentions, and she sure as hell ain't Jezebel. Only time will tell if Arellano's efforts will convert the Pharisees or cause the exile of her people to Babylon — er, Mexico.

I'm African American. At our restaurants, nobody comes to your table to sing to you. At your restaurants, this does happen, and I love it. I love picking out a song (usually something from Luis Miguel's Romance II; it's the best I can do with my limited "ballads en español" repertoire), I love listening to the singer and imagining how many times the group has had to play "La Bamba." Mi problema es I haven't the slightest idea what I should be doing while they're playing. I've usually got a plate of hot food in front of me, or as was the case last Friday night, a waiter trying to outwait the song so he could come take our order. Is it rude to sing along? Do I tip when they're done? How much? Help me not be a clueless tourist when I want to enjoy a little "Media Vuelta" with my #4 combo.
I Wanta Cantar

Dear Want to Sing Negrita: Tips? Always. How much? Depends on how good the mariachi plays. Rude to sing along? Never. Indeed, it's a time-honored tradition amongst Mexicans to have the musically inclined members of la familia belt out a couple of corridos at weddings, quinceañeras, baptisms, or any other celebration (shout-outs to my Tío Ezequiel and cousin Lety!). The dynamic changes a bit when mariachis perform at restaurants, but don't be afraid. Although the crowd will stare and sneer at any non-Mexicans trying to sing mariachi tunes, all you have to do is shout "ˇViva México, cabrones!" at some point, and the wabs will go wild.

ASK A MEXICAN CONTEST! Want a free autographed copy of my book? Send a picture to the e-mail below of yourself or an amigo reading the Mexican while standing outside your local Mexican consulate or embassy. One winner per location only, so the first picture from each region gets the book. Gracias, gente of Albuquerque, Houston, Portland, Dallas, Miami, Las Vegas, San Diego, Phoenix, Prague, Mexico City, Yuma, Salt Lake City, San Antonio, and Tulsa for sending photos. Everyone else: You're going to let fucking Tulsa beat you? Send your photos — ˇándale, ándale!

READER COMMENTS

Editor's Note: Comments are not edited or fact-checked by the East Bay Express.

The mexican Rosa Parks???? Someone has been smoking to much peyote as they smuggle it across the border. I say give the smugglers that smuggle drugs across the border sancuary too. They are poor victims of unjust laws that prevent them from conducting their trade. This woman KNEW it was illegal when she came to the United States and had her anchor baby. She new it was illegal when she used a stolen social security card to work illegally in the United States. NOW she wants to claim she is a victim. Ridiculous!!!! Further, if churches want to interject themselves into the political debate then treat them as a political entity and TAX them like the political animal they wish to be. Remove tax exempt status for churches that wish to politic as opposed to simply observe their religion. Better yet indict the church authorities for aiding and abetting.

Comment by Anonymous - September 13, 2007 @ 08:13 AM

Rosa Parks NO WAY! Most Mexicans have native American DNA to a large part. They own this land it was taken from them and what we have here is American Apartheid KKK nation trying to steal from and deny the natives their land. Yes they are illegal aliens to Euro-Americans but what makes Euro-Americans legal in this country in the first place? because they stole the red man's land and built it up with African slaves? Hooray for the return of the Redman to the continent that is rightfully theirs. My message to white folks that dont like the redman reclaiming their native soil. "put up or ship the Ef back to slovenia"

Comment by Anonymous - September 6, 2007 @ 07:42 AM

Vero: if you want people to respect other races, start with YOURSELF. Cut the crap about "white trash", and stop blaming the white folks for all the problems that have befallen Mexico. The corruption, brutality, and total lack of respect for education, human rights, and private property is a cultural trait of the Mexican political system, not the fault of the gringos up here...

Comment by Anonymous - September 5, 2007 @ 06:45 PM

Read all 4 comments

YOUR COMMENT


RECENT ARTICLES BY GUSTAVO ARELLANO

Putting a name to a crazy, mixed-up heritage.
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
"Speedy González is the most misunderstood Mexican since your gardener."
Wednesday, September 5, 2007

ARCHIVE SEARCH

Select One or More Criteria

NEWS BLOGS

THIS WEEK IN NEWS

Recession be damned, two Oakland entrepreneurs create 21st-century office space.
For years, East Bay activists have been trying to influence US policy toward North Korea. Finally, Washington may be listening.
Sources say the couple's financial troubles could rule out a reelection bid as the mayor is forced to return to lobbying.
Readers sound off on cuts to community colleges, the lost runner, and EBMUD.
The Alameda Boys and Girls Club seeks public funding for its new center, to the consternation of people who say that's not what a 2008 parks bond was for.
New Oakland bar creates a theme out of a term — geisha — that some area residents find offensive.
Lawsuit regarding Oakland's ranked-choice voting.
His prescription for an irritated but inactive people.
Up to ten young men laughed and snapped photos as they allegedly gang-raped a fifteen-year-old girl outside a Richmond High dance. And passersby did nothing to stop it.

MOST POPULAR NEWS STORIES

VIEWED E-MAILED COMMENTED
For years, East Bay activists have been trying to influence US policy toward North Korea. Finally, Washington may be listening.
Cal Professor John Ogbu thinks he knows why rich black kids are failing in school. Nobody wants to hear it.
Local business owners say Yelp offers to hide negative customer reviews of their businesses on its web site ... for a price.
The high-profile rape charges against Deputy District Attorney Michael Gressett are tainted by questionable facts, unorthodox prosecutorial conduct, and the unmistakable whiff of politics.
Lawsuit regarding Oakland's ranked-choice voting.

SPECIAL REPORTS

The definitive guide to the East Bay.
Scavenging, swapping, sharing, sponsoring, recycling, and garage sale-ing.
Out & About, Home & Garden, Food & Drink, and Summer Arts

RECENT ISSUES


Nov 4, 2009

Oct 28, 2009

Oct 21, 2009

Oct 14, 2009

Oct 7, 2009

Sep 30, 2009