Take It, or Leave 

Oakland's Caltrans workers say they were punished for reporting sexual harassment and race discrimination.

If you're female, or black, or both, beware of Caltrans' downtown Oakland office. You could be stalked and sexually assaulted, or passed over for promotion and subjected to racial taunts. Whatever happens, don't complain, because the bosses might blame you and transfer your job elsewhere while leaving your tormentors unpunished.

Those, at least, are the explosive charges leveled by four veteran Caltrans employees — two women and two men — in a pair of lawsuits filed last month against the state transportation agency. If the allegations prove true, taxpayers may be on the hook for huge payouts.

One of the paydays would be for Elena Villareal, a former employee in Caltrans' engineering department, which oversees construction projects including the new eastern span of the Bay Bridge. Villareal alleges that her ordeal lasted more than two years. In court papers, she gave the following account:

Beginning in mid-2003, one of her co-workers, Bing Long, started following her on BART to her home in Pittsburg, even though he lived in Fremont. He would take the same train, and sometimes would be waiting for her on the platform when she got to the station.

Villareal moved to Pacifica several months later, but Long kept pursuing her. He would show up in town on her days off, trailing her to Albertsons, Rite Aid, or her hair stylist. She would confront him. "Why do you keep following me?" she would ask him. "Can you please stop following me?" But inevitably, he would resume the harassment after a short respite.

Co-workers told Villareal that when she left her cubicle, Long often would rifle through her desk, trash can, and purse — that's how she thinks he found out she moved. Then he started showering her with suggestive gifts. First, a present from Victoria's Secret. Then, in August 2004, he gave her a dildo.

Villareal tried to hand it back, but Long allegedly threatened to tell co-workers she'd given it to him. "Women always look bad," he said, adding, "It's for your benefit. I thought you might need it since you don't have a man in your life. If you want, I can come by your place and show you how to use it."

Long then became increasingly aggressive. Once he jumped into the backseat of her car, and when she tried to get him out, he grabbed her and tried to kiss her. He ogled her at work and once grabbed her bra strap. One day in the supply room, he snuck up behind her, rubbed his crotch against her, and tried to fondle her breasts.

She reacted angrily, but several times he said to her: "I know there are a lot of guys out there who like you. But if they can't have you, I'm sure they want to destroy you." Villareal's co-workers told her that in 2005, Long started sending e-mails from her computer when she stepped away from her desk.

Villareal said she and at least one co-worker told supervisors about Long, but they did nothing to stop him. So in December 2005, she met with the engineering department manager, Muhammed Aljabiry, who responded: "You are old enough to take care of yourself. I know you can take care of yourself. I'm sure you have had this problem elsewhere."

After the meeting, Long called Villareal incessantly on her cell phone and sent her angry text messages and pornographic e-mails. Finally, in January 2006, Aljabiry told her he was transferring her out of the department, and that Long was staying. When she asked why, Aljabiry said: "Because you are the one who complained." A few weeks later, Villareal, not her alleged stalker, was reprimanded for sexual harassment.

"It was utterly absurd," Villareal's lawyer, Steven Robinson, told Full Disclosure in an interview last week. "What happened to her was sinister. It was a living hell for her. When she came into our office, she was crying. She was afraid for her well-being."

Caltrans spokeswoman Lauren Wonder said the agency had no comment on Villareal's allegations, citing a long-standing rule not to talk about pending litigation. For the same reason, she declined comment on the second lawsuit.

That one was filed by Danelle McGrue, George Crosby, and Ras Cush, all African Americans who worked in Caltrans' Equal Employment Opportunity Department. Their division aims to ensure that the agency and its contractors do not discriminate, but that, the plaintiffs allege, is exactly what Caltrans did in their case:

Their story began in January 2005, when the three were interviewed for the position of department manager. They knew it was a long shot because, they said, Caltrans had not promoted any person of color from within the ranks of the Oakland office for thirteen years. Indeed, they and other black employees had met with Caltrans officials several times the year before to voice their complaints, but got nowhere.

Then, sure enough, Caltrans hired Esther Vicente, an employee from outside the department, even though she had no prior experience handling discrimination issues. Even one of the interviewers, Ruby Louie, the assistant director of external affairs (translation: press flack), admitted Vicente was unqualified.

Once Vicente took over, she made workers' lives miserable. She often yelled at Cush and told them not to protest her promotion. Barely a week into the job, she called together all of the black employees. "You people are not accountable," she allegedly told them. "You are not doing your jobs and are not working up to your ability."

Later, Vicente told a group of white employees that black workers don't like to work and don't come to work on time, calling them "lazy" and "shiftless."

McGrue, Crosby, and Cush took their allegations to Louie and other Caltrans officials, including Bijan Sartipi, director of the Oakland office, but nothing happened. Soon thereafter, Vicente issued Cush a letter of reprimand, claiming his work was substandard. One day later, Caltrans officials transferred Cush to the facilities department. "All three were eventually reassigned," plaintiffs' attorney Pamela Price told Full Disclosure.

Maybe it's time to reassign some of Oakland's top Caltrans officials before they cost us a fortune in legal bills.

Less Than Transparent

Oakland Mayor Ron Dellums' salary recently was Topic A around City Hall after the city council raised it to $183,000. The San Francisco Chronicle reported that the ex-congressman also gets a federal pension that may be worth at least $100,000 a year. But one unanswered question is how much Dellums can legally add to that total from his Washington, DC, lobbying firm.

Upon taking office, Dellums reported on his statement of economic interests that he made more than $100,000 last year as senior partner of Dellums and Associates. The disclosure form does not require him to be more specific. His clients included Rolls-Royce, Chabot Space and Science Center, and the AIDS Healthcare Foundation.

The Oakland City Charter, however, clearly forbids him from continuing as a lobbyist. Section 305(h) reads: "The mayor shall devote his full time and attention to the duties of the Office of Mayor and shall not engage in outside employment while in office."

But the charter has a loophole. It lets a mayor collect "income earned from businesses or investments in which he is not actively engaged." Ex-Mayor Jerry Brown, for example, used the loophole in 2005 when he pocketed $1.7 million from the sale of the Jack London Square Warehouse that housed his nonprofit, We the People.

Dellums, who has vowed to restore "transparency" to city government, has said he has given up active lobbying, but won't say whether he'll continue to collect on his firm's profits. When asked about Dellums' current role in the lobbying firm, mayoral spokeswoman Karen Stevenson would not comment, and referred Full Disclosure to Charles Stephenson, who has taken over as principal of Dellums and Associates. Stephenson did not return two phone calls seeking comment.

So, Mr. Mayor, why the secrecy?

Comments (4) RSS

Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

You fail to mention in this article that Esther Vicente is African American.

Posted by plzook1838 on March 21, 2007 at 12:45 PM | Report this comment

Pat, I'm looking into it.

Posted by robert.gammon on March 21, 2007 at 1:08 PM | Report this comment

Just a comment about Esther being a EEO officer I wish she would do something beside's just sitting there! Now after reading this article I totally agree that she's not the person for this Job far as being the one to Blame because of the supervisor's neglegence and the harrasment that some of us endured. Her helping me with my forms and giving advice was far as referals,was exactly what I needed. She also told me that I would be placed on rejection during probation after filing my complaint. And she was very helpful the day I stumbled in her office crying and shaken do to the abuse that I endured in the Comm Center on the Fifth Floor of the building 111 Grand Ave. Esther is not to Blame. It's the people that just come to work with Sex and Play on there mind and not work and respect for other's.

Posted by goddessofthebay2587 on July 18, 2007 at 4:26 AM | Report this comment

Silly story.

Posted by 1236828 on October 12, 2007 at 10:19 PM | Report this comment

Latest in Full Disclosure

  • You Don't Know Jack

    There's strong evidence that Marcel Diallo Jack, the self-styled "mayor of West Oakland," perpetrated a racist Internet fraud on a local activist.
    • Nov 18, 2009
  • Oakland Ethics Commissioner Has Ethics Problem

    Oakland Public Ethics Commissioner Alex Paul is the domestic partner of a lobbyist and powerful PAC chairman. Plus, the city's police union breaks the law for Perata.
    • Nov 11, 2009
  • Dellums Fails to Pay at Least $239,000 in Taxes

    Sources say the couple's financial troubles could rule out a reelection bid as the mayor is forced to return to lobbying.
    • Nov 4, 2009
  • More»

Author Archives

Calendar

Submit an event

Most Popular Stories

  • You Don't Know Jack

    There's strong evidence that Marcel Diallo Jack, the self-styled "mayor of West Oakland," perpetrated a racist Internet fraud on a local activist.
  • Yelp and the Business of Extortion 2.0

    Local business owners say Yelp offers to hide negative customer reviews of their businesses on its web site ... for a price.
  • A Coach's Job Begins Off the Court

    Coach Joanne Boyle has built the Cal women's basketball program by treating team members as people as well as players.
  • Das Mann of Steel

    How a metalworker from Burning Man became the maestro of the huge American Steel artist complex.
  • Understanding North Korea

    For years, East Bay activists have been trying to influence US policy toward North Korea. Finally, Washington may be listening.

© 2009 East Bay Express    All Rights Reserved