Surviving the Match 

For thousands of fledgling doctors like Adam Warren, the future hinges on a single day in March.

Every year on the third Monday in March, medical school deans across the nation warn their senior students to stay alert for a pager call. Worse than a late-night code blue, that ring, if it comes, portends terrible news.

Stanford medical student Adam Warren's pager went off that Monday in 2004, and when he saw the number of the dean's office on its screen, the blood drained from his face. He called the office, and the staffer on the other end confirmed his fears: After six years of intensive medical training, he'd struck out in the lottery that places students in residency training positions. Without a residency, Warren had no job, no prospects for becoming a surgeon, and no salary to pay off his massive student debt.

Warren had dreamed of being an orthopedic surgeon since high school. An energetic and muscular athlete, he was then a track standout who later played football for UC Berkeley. Between his own inevitable injuries and those of his teammates, he developed close relationships with the athletic trainers and sports medicine specialists, which only strengthened his career ambition. During his pre-med dance at Cal, Warren developed an interest in immunology and supported himself by working in labs, including a stint at Emeryville's Chiron Corporation. His scientific aptitude earned him a slot in Stanford's prestigious medical program.

Warren kept an open mind about his prospects. When Stanford researchers, noting his lab skills, urged him to get a Ph.D, he pursued it for two years. But then he returned to med-school classes, concluding he didn't want to be a scientist.

Pediatric surgery also tempted Warren, and he so impressed Stanford doctors during his third year that one pediatric transplant surgeon offered him a general surgery residency a full year before anyone else could apply. But the job came with strings attached. "There was an unwritten rule that I'd have to first go and prove myself on their surgery trips to the developing world," Warren recalled. "Plus, neither Stanford nor general or pediatric surgery felt right." He would have had to toil for five years on adult gallbladder removals and amputations before getting to operate on kids.

Orthopedic surgery was what Warren really wanted. So he did what every medical student must do. He entered the Match.

The Match is the complex lottery used to place medical students in residency programs at the nation's teaching hospitals. It's a make-or-break moment in a young doctor's career. These programs are where physicians are trained in their specialties and become eligible for certification by the state medical board. Across the nation this week, tens of thousands of budding MDs receive the match results that will profoundly affect their life direction. The news will in large part dictate where they live and work for the next three to seven years, what field of medicine they practice, and their future earning potential.

While a medical school acceptance letter is popularly seen as a ticket to autonomy and financial comfort, the Match turns the nation's future neurosurgeons and cardiologists into hapless supplicants compelled to juggle their hospital duties with applications, interviews, and cross-country hospital visits. The process can be nerve-racking, exhilarating, or devastating. And for those who think strong scores and great letters of recommendation are tickets to success, the inherent subjectivity of the Match can come as a rude awakening. The results can alternatively jumpstart a glorious career at a prestigious hospital or place a fledgling physician in an inferior training program far from where he or she wants to be.

"The Match is stupid," says David Goldenberg, a journalist whose wife, Sara Thierman, is preparing for the 2007 Dermatology match. The San Francisco couple wants to live near family in Alabama or New York City, but they know they could end up anywhere. "Its full purpose is to drive students crazy. It's a load of pressure — you may end up here, you may not; might match, might not. Pretty much everyone is unhappy."

Even in the best-case scenario, the Match sentences recent med-school grads to at least three years of low wages for the privilege of treating the patients of attending hospital physicians at all hours of the night.

In Warren's case, it left him unemployed.


The Match

The National Resident Matching Program was established in 1952 to make the residency application process less chaotic. Before that, top contenders might sit on offers from multiple programs while holding out for their first choices, leaving less-competitive applicants in limbo for months. For the latter group, this meant eleventh-hour moves across the country as the cards fell where they might. Like pro sports teams, hospitals would compete for prime students by extending offers as early as the sophomore year of medical school. Some sent "exploding" offers that would expire in 24 to 48 hours if the applicant did not reply.

The Match is actually several matches. The largest, which takes place this week, is that of the National Resident Matching Program, catering to internal medicine, family practice, pediatrics, and other specialties. The American Urological Association runs its own match for urology programs. Finally, the San Francisco Matching Program handles ophthalmology, neurosurgery, pediatric neurology, and plastic surgery. Hopefuls submit their applications in the fall, and the newly minted doctors typically start their residencies the following July.

Comments (7) RSS

Showing 1-5 of 7

Add a comment | All comments »

Sara thierman has no h in her first name. I know, i am her father.

Posted by thiermanaaef on March 13, 2007 at 10:01 PM | Report this comment

As a current medical student getting ready to see the results of where i matched tomorrow, i think this is an extremely well done article. All of your facts were accurate, and really grasp the emotions and sentiments of fourth year medical students. Great Job!

Posted by hbpb1397e3 on March 14, 2007 at 3:51 PM | Report this comment

It would have been nice if you would have credited your sources such as studentdoctor.net. As well as even though you got PM permission, it was for a class, not for publication. Journalism ethics ...

Posted by nab2a8 on March 20, 2007 at 4:01 AM | Report this comment

Eye opening especially to all the pre-meds out there who imagine the med school application process to be their greatest challenge. Knowledge is power and your article shows great insight into this additional step of becoming an MD.

Posted by lakecostello884e on March 21, 2007 at 6:11 AM | Report this comment

Excellent article. As a medical student it is very hard to convey to people outside of the medical field just what the match is and how it works and how daunting it is. This article does that very well.

Posted by derkjohnson79e9f4 on March 23, 2007 at 2:11 PM | Report this comment

Latest in Feature

  • A Coach's Job Begins Off the Court

    Coach Joanne Boyle has built the Cal women's basketball program by treating team members as people as well as players.
    • Nov 18, 2009
  • Das Mann of Steel

    How a metalworker from Burning Man became the maestro of the huge American Steel artist complex.
    • Nov 11, 2009
  • Understanding North Korea

    For years, East Bay activists have been trying to influence US policy toward North Korea. Finally, Washington may be listening.
    • Nov 4, 2009
  • More»

Author Archives

Calendar

Submit an event

Most Popular Stories

  • You Don't Know Jack

    There's strong evidence that Marcel Diallo Jack, the self-styled "mayor of West Oakland," perpetrated a racist Internet fraud on a local activist.
  • Yelp and the Business of Extortion 2.0

    Local business owners say Yelp offers to hide negative customer reviews of their businesses on its web site ... for a price.
  • A Troubled Rape Case

    The high-profile rape charges against Deputy District Attorney Michael Gressett are tainted by questionable facts, unorthodox prosecutorial conduct, and the unmistakable whiff of politics.
  • Sir Dyno's Deal with the Devil

    Rapper David Rocha thought a norteño gangsta CD was his ticket to glory -- not life in prison.
  • Rich, Black, Flunking

    Cal Professor John Ogbu thinks he knows why rich black kids are failing in school. Nobody wants to hear it.

© 2009 East Bay Express    All Rights Reserved